Congressman Stearns responded to the Association’s appeal, and sent a letter to William Tuerk of the Department of Veteran Affairs.
William Tuerk responded to the Association in the negative. Dick Rohde indicates:
a. It is my understanding that Mr. Rinker knew that the monument represented the three ships.
b. There are not three ship’s associations, only two. SBR Survivors Association and Johnston/Hoel Association.
c We already have a space at the cemetery for the bronze plaque, on the existing monument.
d. I am not aware of a “Johnston/Hoel/Roberts Monument Committee”.
Click on the image below to see the letter.
Text of the letter follows.
January 22, 2008
The Honorable William F. Tuerk
Under Secretary for Memorial Affairs Department of Veterans Affairs
National Cemetery Association
810 Vermont Avenue
Washington, DC 20420
I am writing on behalf of the Samuel B. Roberts Survivors Association. The USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS, DE 413 was a part of Task Unit 77.4.3 known as Taffy 3, involved in the battle of Leyte Gulf in October of 1944. It, together with USS HOEL, DD 533 and USS JOHNSTON, DD 557, were sunk by shellfire from the Japanese fleet in that battle. The efforts of Taffy 3 resulted in the saving of the Philippine invasion and our being awarded the Presidential Unit Citation.
A granite monument honoring our shipmates who died in that battle was dedicated at Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery in San Diego in 1995. This letter is in response to information we have received regarding a ruling you recently made concerning our monument.
Several granite monuments were erected honoring those Taffy 3 sailors who perished in the battle. Through time, the monuments deteriorated to the point the names were difficult, if not impossible, to read. Other ships installed bronze plaques over their existing monuments to resolve that problem. We, the Samuel B. Roberts Survivors Association, decided to rectify that problem in the same manner. We solicited funds from our membership and friends, including family members of those killed, toward that end.
We raised the $10,000 we were told was needed for the plaque for the USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS portion of the monument and then discovered the Johnston/Hoel Association decided not to do anything with their sections of the monument. At that point, we learned from the then Director of the National Cemetery, Bill Livingston, that he did not think that it would “look right” if we were to improve only our part of the monument and we were denied our request to have the plaque installed over the USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS section of the monument.
We then decided to look elsewhere for a way to honor our lost comrades, in a manner so that their names would not fade away. We found that the Nimitz Museum, also known as the Museum of the Pacific in Fredericksburg, Texas, was willing, for consideration, to name a pavilion and gazebo after our ship. We decided to go ahead with that project.
Just before we formally agreed to the Texas project, I contacted the cemetery in San Diego to make certain it was maintaining its position of denying our request to improve the monument in San Diego, since that was the original basis for our fund raising project. I spoke with the Interim Director, Charles Kahler, as Mr. Livingston was then away on a special assignment. I explained the situation to Mr. Kahler. He was familiar with our monument. He said he thought adding the bronze plaque was a good idea but he would have to talk with his supervisor, Don Rinker. Mr. Kahler thought, as we did, that once the Johnston/Hoel people saw our bronze plaque they would be inclined to do the same. I was then informed by Mr. Kahler that he had spoken with Mr. Rinker and Mr. Rinker had approved the project. I told him I would need something in writing before I committed our Association to an expense of almost $10,000. Mr. Kahler then emailed me a copy of Mr. Rinker’s email which approved of the project, and told me to “go ahead”. Based on that approval, we proceeded.
Seaman-Poe Monument Company of San Diego was contacted. We signed a contract with it for a bronze plaque to go over the names on our portion of the monument. The total cost including installation and tax was $9,143.14, which we paid on April 30, 2007. This completed 28″ x 55″ x .5″ bronze casting is currently being held by Seaman-Poe Monument Company.
It is my understanding that Glen Foster, a member of the Johnston/Hoel Association, objected to the installation. Mr. Foster apparently stated he was the chairman of the USS JOHNSTON-USS HOEL-USS SB ROBERTS monument committee. He may have been the chairman of a committee during the planning stages, but I do not know that to be a fact. In any event, the memorial was completed and then turned over to Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery. If this committee still exists, there has never been a meeting to which any members of the Samuel B. Roberts Survivors Association have been invited or attended. Indeed, we are unaware of any reason for the continuance of this supposed committee since the memorial has been deeded over to the cemetery.
As you might suspect, we, the Samuel B. Roberts Association, are quite upset with your decision about the monument. We do not understand why we were not consulted about this matter. Officials of Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery were well aware of our existence and our interest in the bronze plaque. We do not understand why we would be provided with verbal and written authority to go forward with the project and then, after we relied on that authority, are being told the plaque we purchased cannot be used. We want the bronze plaque on the monument to preserve the names of our fallen shipmates.
We earnestly and respectfully request you reconsider your decision in this matter. Not only have we expended considerable funds based on approval from officials of the National Cemetery Association, but also have planned a reunion in San Diego in October of 2008 to rededicate the memorial with the new bronze name plate for our fallen shipmates. We fully respect the right of our sister ships, USS HOEL and USS JOHNSTON, to decide not to improve their portion of the monument but do not feel they should be able to deny us our right to improve our portion. We do not believe it is appropriate that one person, claiming to be chairman of a non-existent committee, should be able to thwart our desire to preserve the names of our fallen shipmates.
Our first hope, of course, is that in reconsidering your decision, you will allow us to install the bronze plaque. Please allow us, in the short time we have remaining on this earth, to honor our fallen shipmates in a way that will allow their names to remain after we are no longer here. If you are unwilling to grant us this request, we would expect you would reimburse us the $9,143.14 we spent in reliance on the cemetery’s telling us we could have the bronze plaque installed on the existing monument.
We look forward to hearing back from you in this matter. Thank you in advance for your consideration.
Richard K. Rohde, for the Samuel B. Roberts Survivors Association
cc: Directors of SBR Association
Kirk Leopard, Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery
Peggy Haleen, Seaman-Poe Monument Company
Charles Kahler, Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery
Donald Rinker, National Cemetery Association
Seven survivors, family and friends of the USS Samuel B. Roberts Survivors Association gathered in the Washington DC area at the Springfield Hilton Hotel for their reunion. In all, 27 were present during the period from September 26th to September 30th.
The U.S. Navy Memorial was the site for our Memorial Service on Thursday. The weather was perfect and the staff of the Navy Memorial could not have been more helpful. The bell was sounded three times for shipmates who took their final voyage since our last reunion. They were Executive Officer Everett E. “Bob” Roberts and close friends Seamen George Bray and Sam Blue. Along with the Navy Honor Guard and Navy Bugler, we were pleased to have old friend John Cosgrove in attendance. Following luncheon, we then visited the most impressive World War II Memorial. On returning to the hotel we had our annual business meeting. San Diego is our proposed site for next year’s gathering.
On Friday, we visited Arlington National Cemetery and witnessed the changing of the guard at the Tomb of the Unknowns. No matter how many times you may see this, it never diminishes in honor and respect. One cannot forget the words from the Sentinel’s Creed, “…. this soldier will in honored glory rest under my eternal vigilance”. Following a luncheon at the Mount Vernon Inn, we toured Mount Vernon, the home of George Washington. This is indeed a magnificent home in a beautiful setting.
Saturday evening, following a social hour, we enjoyed a delicious meal served by our hotel. Special guests this evening included CDR Mark Metzger and his wife Dalia. Mark is the Prospective Commanding Officer of USS CARR, FFG 52, named after our shipmate Paul Henry Carr. The Change of Command will take place in October somewhere in the Middle East. Former CO of USS CARR, Ned Bagley and his wife Catriona had planned to be with us for dinner but airline delays changed their plans. Ned did join us for breakfast on Sunday morning. Our speaker for the evening was Brad Peniston, author of the book “No Higher Honor” which chronicles the story of the mining of our namesake ship USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS, FFG 58, in the Persian Gulf in 1988. Even though many of us had read his superb book, he made the story come alive. Following the presentation of long stemmed roses to our ladies, we moved on to our hospitality room for songs, stories and farewells.
Sunday morning most of us gathered for our Farewell Breakfast. Vows to meet again next year were followed by our return to our homes from one coast to the other. Fair winds and following seas to all.
Dick Rohde, interviewed 3/29/2007 on Ocala’s WOCA radio.
Real Audio format
3/29/2007 on Ocala’s WOCA radio (requires free RealPlayer basic. Note — it will download in full before starting. This may take some time depending on your connection to the internet.)